21-05 - MCS Industries, Inc. v. COSCO Shipping Lines Co., Ltd. and MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA


Last Updated: 05/04/2022


Document NumberDocument Serve DateDescriptionDocument
107/28/2021Received Verified ComplaintReceived Verified Complaint.pdf21-05_Complaint.pdf 46668
208/03/2021Served Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment Served Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment.pdf21-05_Notice_Filingnosig.pdf 46669
308/04/2021Served Order Designating Administrative Law JudgeServed Order Designating Administrative Law Judge.pdf21-05_Order_Design_ALJ.pdf 46677
408/04/2021Served Initial OrderServed Initial Order.pdf21-05_Initial_Order.pdf 46678
508/25/2021Received Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A.'s Notice of Appearance for Michael Scanlon, John Longstreth, and Ifigeneia XanthopoulouReceived Respondent's Notice of Appearance for Michael Scanlon, John Longstreth, and Ifigeneia Xanthopoulou.pdf21-05_Respondent_NOA.pdf 47696
608/26/2021Received Verified Answer of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A.Received Verified Answer of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A..pdf21-05_Respondent_Verified_Answer.pdf 47698
708/30/2021Received Respondent COSCO Shipping Lines Co., Ltd's Notice of Appearance Matthew J. Thomas and Keith B. LetourneauReceived Respondent COSCO Shipping Lines Co., Ltd's Notice of Appearance Matthew J. Thomas and Keith B. Letourneau.pdf21-05_COSCO_NOA.pdf 47701
808/30/2021Received Respondent COSCO Shipping Lines, Co., LTD's Answer to Verified ComplaintReceived Respondent COSCO Shipping Lines, Co., LTD's Answer to Verified Complaint.pdf21-05_CSL_Answer_Complaint.pdf 47702
909/03/2021Received Respondent's Motion for Enlargement of Time for Exchange of Initial DisclosuresReceived Respondent's Motion for Enlargement of Time for Exchange of Initial Disclosures.pdf21-05_COSCO_Mtn_Enlargement.pdf 47736
1009/07/2021Served Order Granting Extension of Time to Exchange Initial DisclosuresServed Order Granting Extension of Time to Exchange Initial Disclosures.pdf21-05_Ext_Intl_Discl.pdf 47737
1109/10/2021Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Approval of Settlement and to Preserve Confidentiality of SettlementReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Approval of Settlement and to Preserve Confidentiality of Settlement.pdf21-05_Compl_Mtn_Approval_Settlement_and_Confidentiality.pdf 47754
1209/10/2021Received Cover Page for Public Redacted Exhibit to Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Approval of Settlement and to Preserve Confidentiality of Settlement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Cover Page for Public Redacted Exhibit to Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Approval of Settlement and to Preserve Confidentiality of Settlement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions).pdf21-05_Coverpage_Public_Version_Exhibit.pdf 47755
1309/20/2021Received Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery ScheduleReceived Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery Schedule.pdf21-05_JSR_Proposd_Disc_Schd.pdf 47797
1409/23/2021Served Initial Decision Approving Confidential Settlement AgreementServed Initial Decision Approving Confidential Settlement Agreement.pdf21-05_Settlement_Cosco.pdf 47799
1509/23/2021Served Scheduling OrderServed Scheduling Order.pdf21-05_Schedule_Order.pdf 47800
1610/08/2021Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Submission of Disputes Concerning Scope of Initial RFPSReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Submission of Disputes Concerning Scope of Initial RFPS.pdf21-05_MCS_Submission_Disputes.pdf 48815
1710/12/2021Received Response of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company to Complainant's "Submission of Disputes Concerning Scope of Initial Request for Production"Received Response of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company to Complainant's "Submission of Disputes Concerning Scope of Initial Request for Production".pdf21-05_Respondent_Response_MCS_Submission_Disputes.pdf 48816
1810/26/2021Served Notice Not to ReviewServed Notice Not to Review.pdf21-05_Notice_Not_Reviewnosig.pdf 50842
1911/16/2021Received Joint Motion for Entry of Confidentiality Stipulation and Proposed Protective Order with AppendixReceived Joint Motion for Entry of Confidentiality Stipulation and Proposed Protective Order with Appendix.pdf21-05_Jt_Mtn_Entry_Confid_Stipulation_Protective_Order.pdf 50856
2011/18/2021Served Order Entering Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective OrderServed Order Entering Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective Order.pdf21-05_Order_Confid_Stip.pdf 50857
2111/22/2021Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion to Compel Discovery from Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SAReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion to Compel Discovery from Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA.pdf21-05_Compl_Mtn_Compel.pdf 51853
2211/22/2021Received Declaration of Matthew J. Reynolds in Support of Complainant's Motion to Compel Discovery from Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA with ExhibitsReceived Declaration of Matthew J. Reynolds in Support of Complainant's Motion to Compel Discovery from Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA with Exhibits.pdf21-05_Reynolds_Decl_Exhibits.pdf 51854
2311/29/2021Received Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A's Counterstatements and Opposition the Motion to Compel, or in the Alternative, Request to Defer its Consideration Pending Resolution of a Motion for Summary Disposition with CONFIDENTIAL ExhibitsReceived Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A's Counterstatements and Opposition the Motion to Compel, or in the Alternative, Request to Defer its Consideration Pending Resolution of a Motion for Summary Disposition with CONFIDENTIAL Exhibits.pdf21-05_MSC_Counterstatement_and_Opposition.pdf 51867
2412/02/2021Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Notice of New Developments regarding Motion to Compel Discovery From Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SAReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Notice of New Developments regarding Motion to Compel Discovery From Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA.pdf21-05_Complainant_Notice_New_Develop.pdf 51868
2512/03/2021Received Response of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Complainant's "Notice of New Developments" and Its Request that the Presiding Officer "Decide Complainant's Request to Extend the Discovery Schedule on an Expeditated Basis" with ExhibitsReceived Response of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Complainant's "Notice of New Developments" and Its Request that the Presiding Officer "Decide Complainant's Request to Extend the Discovery Schedule on an Expeditated Basis" with Exhibits.pdf21-05_Respondent_Response_Notice_New_Developments.pdf 51873
2612/03/2021Received Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A.'s Motion for Confidential Treatment with Exhibits (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A.'s Motion for Confidential Treatment with Exhibits (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Version.pdf21-05_Respondent_Mtn_Confidential_Treatment_Exhibits.pdf 51874
2712/08/2021Served Order Granting Motion to CompelServed Order Granting Motion to Compel.pdf21-05_Order_Motion_Compel.pdf 51875
2812/20/2021Received Joint Status Report and Proposed Revised Discovery ScheduleReceived Joint Status Report and Proposed Revised Discovery Schedule.pdf21-05_JSR_Schedule.pdf 53889
2912/21/2021Served Revised Scheduling OrderServed Revised Scheduling Order.pdf21-05_Revised_Schedule_Order.pdf 53890
3012/23/2021Received Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A's Motion for Confidential TreatmentReceived Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A's Motion for Confidential Treatment.pdf21-05_Revised_Mtn_Confidential_Treatment.pdf 54898
3112/23/2021Received Respondent's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in it's Entirety, or as to Count V in the Alternative for Summary Disposition with Exhibits (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Respondent's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in it's Entirety, or as to Count V in the Alternative for Summary Disposition with Exhibits (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions).pdf21-05_Revised_Mtn_Dismiss_with_public_Exhibits.pdf 54899
3212/23/2021Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Permission to File Verified Amended Complaint Against Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SAReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Motion for Permission to File Verified Amended Complaint Against Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA.pdf21-05_Complainant_Mtn_Permission_File_Amended_Complaint.pdf 54900
3312/30/2021Received Opposition of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Complainant's Motion for Leave to File an Amended Complaint with ExhibitsReceived Opposition of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Complainant's Motion for Leave to File an Amended Complaint with Exhibits.pdf21-05_Opposition_Complainant_Mtn_Amended_Complaint_Exhibits.pdf 54905
3401/07/2022Received Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Memorandum in Opposition to Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in its Entirety, or as to Count V in the Alternative for Summary DispositionReceived Complainant MCS Industries, Inc.'s Memorandum in Opposition to Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company SA's Motion to Dismiss the Complaint in its Entirety, or as to Count V in the Alternative for Summary Disposition.pdf21-05_MCS_Opposition_MSC_Mtn_Dismiss.pdf 54918
3501/10/2022Received Joint Status ReportReceived Joint Status Report.pdf21-05_JSR_January22.pdf 54919
3601/14/2022Received Respondent's Reply in Support of Respondent's Motion to DismissReceived Respondent's Reply in Support of Respondent's Motion to Dismiss.pdf21-05_Respondent_MSC_Reply_Supporting_Mtn_Dismiss.pdf 55922
3702/04/2022Served Order on Motion to Amend Complaint and Motion to DismissServed Order on Motion to Amend Complaint and Motion to Dismiss.pdf21-05_Order_Dismiss_Amend_Complaint.pdf 57941
3802/04/2022Received Verified Amended ComplaintReceived Verified Amended Complaint.pdf21-05_Amended_Complaint.pdf 57942
3902/24/2022Received Verified Answer of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Verified Amended ComplaintReceived Verified Answer of Respondent MSC Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A. to Verified Amended Complaint.pdf21-05_Respondent_Answer_Amended_Complaint.pdf 57976
4002/25/2022Received Respondent's Notice and Update on Joint Status Report with AttachmentReceived Respondent's Notice and Update on Joint Status Report with Attachment.pdf21-05_Notice_Status_Report_with_Attachment.pdf 57993
4102/28/2022Received Joint Status ReportReceived Joint Status Report.pdf21-05_JSR_2-28-22.pdf 57995
4203/04/2022Served Order on Proposed Revised Schedule and Discovery NoticeServed Order on Proposed Revised Schedule and Discovery Notice.pdf21-05_Discovery_Order.pdf 59002
4304/04/2022Received Joint Status ReportReceived Joint Status Report.pdf21-05_JSR_4-4-22.pdf 61073
4405/04/2022Served Order Granting Request for Letter of Request Under Hague ConventionServed Order Granting Request for Letter of Request Under Hague Convention.pdf21-05_Order_Hague_Letter_Request.pdf 62178