21-11 - OJ Commerce, LLC v. Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft A/S & Co KG and Hamburg Sud North America, Inc.


Last Updated: 12/23/2022


Document NumberDocument Serve DateDescriptionDocument
111/23/2021Received Verified ComplaintReceived Verified Complaint.pdf21-11_Complaint.pdf 52877
212/13/2021Served Notice of Filing of Complaint and AssignmentServed Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment.pdf21-11_Notice_Filingnosig.pdf 52878
312/14/2021Served Order Designating Administrative Law JudgeServed Order Designating Administrative Law Judge.pdf21-11_Order_Design_ALJ.pdf 52883
412/14/2021Served Initial OrderServed Initial Order.pdf21-11_Initial_Order.pdf 52884
512/17/2021Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment appeared in Federal Register 86 FR 71639 (initial decision due: December 13, 2022; final decision due: June 27, 2023)Notice of Filing of Complaint and Assignment appeared in Federal Register 86 FR 71639 (initial decision due: December 13, 2022; final decision due: June 27, 2023).pdf21-11_FR_Notice.pdf 53885
612/23/2021Received Respondent's Notice of Appearance for Wayne R. Rohde and Kathryn SobottaReceived Respondent's Notice of Appearance for Wayne R. Rohde and Kathryn Sobotta.pdf21-11_Respondent_NOA.pdf 53893
712/23/2021Received Respondents' Motion for Extension of Time to File AnswerReceived Respondents' Motion for Extension of Time to File Answer.pdf21-11_Mtn_Ext_Time.pdf 54891
812/29/2021Served Order Granting Extension of Time to File AnswerServed Order Granting Extension of Time to File Answer.pdf21-11_Ext_Answer.pdf 54897
901/18/2022Received Partial Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft A/S & Co. KGReceived Partial Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft A/S & Co. KG.pdf21-11_Respondent_Answer.pdf 55928
1001/18/2022Received Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary JudgmentReceived Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgment.pdf21-11_Respondent_Mtn_Dismiss.pdf 55929
1101/18/2022Received Respondents' Memorandum in Support of Respondents Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgment with ExhibitsReceived Respondents' Memorandum in Support of Respondents Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgment with Exhibits.pdf21-11_Memo_Supporting_Respondent_Mtn_Dismiss.pdf 55930
1202/02/2022Received Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Motion for Leave to File Verified Amended Complaint Against Respondents and Memorandum of Law Related TheretoReceived Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Motion for Leave to File Verified Amended Complaint Against Respondents and Memorandum of Law Related Thereto.pdf21-11_Complainant_Mtn_Leave_File_Amended_Complaint.pdf 57932
1302/02/2022Received Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Opposition to Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary JudgmentReceived Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Opposition to Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgment.pdf21-11_Complainant_Opposition_Mtn_Dismiss.pdf 57933
1402/07/2022Received Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery ScheduleReceived Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery Schedule.pdf21-11_JSR_Propsd_Discovery_Sched.pdf 57948
1502/07/2022Received Respondents' Opposition to Complainant's Motion for Leave to File Verified Amended ComplaintReceived Respondents' Opposition to Complainant's Motion for Leave to File Verified Amended Complaint.pdf21-11_Opposition_Motion_Leave.pdf 57949
1602/07/2022Received Respondents' Reply to Complainant's Opposition to Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary JudgmentReceived Respondents' Reply to Complainant's Opposition to Respondents' Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgment.pdf21-11_Reply_Oppostion_Motion_Dismiss.pdf 57950
1702/18/2022Served Order on Motion to Amend Complaint and Motion to DismissServed Order on Motion to Amend Complaint and Motion to Dismiss.pdf21-11_Order_Amend_Complaint_Motion_Dismiss.pdf 57965
1802/18/2022Received Verified Amended ComplaintReceived Verified Amended Complaint.pdf21-11_Verified_Amended Complaint.pdf 57966
1903/01/2022Received Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft A/S & Co Kg to Amended ComplaintReceived Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft A/S & Co Kg to Amended Complaint.pdf21-11_Respondent_Hamburg_Sudamerikanische_Answer_Amended_Complaint.pdf 57997
2003/01/2022Received Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sud North America, Inc. to Amended ComplaintReceived Answer of Respondent Hamburg Sud North America, Inc. to Amended Complaint.pdf21-11_Respondent_Hamburg_North_America_Answer_Amended_Complaint.pdf 57998
2103/08/2022Received Second Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery ScheduleReceived Second Joint Status Report and Proposed Discovery Schedule.pdf21-11_2nd_JSR.pdf 59016
2203/10/2022Served Scheduling OrderServed Scheduling Order.pdf21-11_Scheduling_Order.pdf 60009
2304/11/2022Received Joint Status ReportReceived Joint Status Report.pdf21-11_JSR.pdf 61092
2404/25/2022Received Joint Motion for Entry of Confidentiality Stipulation and Proposed Protective OrderReceived Joint Motion for Entry of Confidentiality Stipulation and Proposed Protective Order.pdf21-11_Joint_Mtn_Protective_Order.pdf 62166
2504/26/2022Served Order Entering Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective OrderServed Order Entering Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective Order.pdf21-11_Protective_Order.pdf 62162
2605/16/2022Received Joint Motion to Modify Scheduling OrderReceived Joint Motion to Modify Scheduling Order.pdf21-11_joint_mtn_Mod_ Sch_Ord.pdf 63209
2705/16/2022Received Complainant's Motion to Compel and for ReimbursementReceived Complainant's Motion to Compel and for Reimbursement.pdf21-11_Comp_Mtn_Compel_Reimb.pdf 64207
2805/23/2022Respondents’ Response to Complainant’s Motion to CompelRespondents’ Response to Complainant’s Motion to Compel.pdfLEGAL 58052493v1 Response to MTC.PDF 64219
2906/21/2022Received Joint Motion for Amendment of Protective OrderJoint Motion for Amendment of Protective Order.pdf21-11_Jt_Mtn_PO.pdf 67282
3006/22/2022Served Order Entering Amended Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective OrderOrder Entering Amended Confidentiality Stipulation and Protective Order.pdf21-11_Rvsd_P_O.pdf 67284
3106/29/2022Served Order on Respondents' Motion to Compel and Revised ScheduleOrder on Respondents' Motion to Compel and Revised Schedule.pdf21-11_Ord_R_Mtn_S.pdf 67296
3207/13/2022Received Notice of AppearanceReceived Notice of Appearance.pdfLEGAL 58681960v1 Notice of Appearance.PDF 68313
3307/15/2022Received Joint Status ReportJoint Status Report.pdf21-11_JSR.pdf 69311
3407/25/2022Received Notice of AppearanceReceived Notice of Appearance.pdf21-11 Notice of Appearance.pdf 69318
3507/25/2022Received Notice of AppearanceReceived Notice of Appearance.pdf21-11 Notice of Appearance(1).pdf 69319
3607/26/2022Received Respondents' Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits)Received Respondents' Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions).pdf21-11_R_MtD_Public.pdf 70321
3708/10/2022Received Complainant’s Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Respondents’ Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits)Received Complainant’s Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Respondents’ Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgement (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits).pdf21-11_C_Opp_R_MtD_Pub_wo_Ex.pdf 71325
3808/15/2022Received Request for Expedited Briefing and Consideration (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits)Request for Expedited Briefing and Consideration (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits).pdf21-11_C_Request_Public_wo_Exhibits.pdf 72343
3908/17/2022Received Respondents’ Reply to Complainant’s Opposition to Respondents’ Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary JudgementRespondents’ Reply to Complainant’s Opposition to Respondents’ Partial Motion to Dismiss and/or for Summary Judgement.pdf21-11_R_Rply_C_Opposition.pdf 72344
4008/22/2022Received Respondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Expedited ReliefRespondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Expedited Relief.pdf21-11_R_Opp_C_Relief.pdf 72364
4108/22/2022Received Respondents’ Motion for Protective OrderRespondents’ Motion for Protective Order.pdf21-11_R_Mtn_PO.pdf 72365
4108/24/2022Received Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC’s Response to Respondents’ Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum of Law Related Thereto (Public and CONFIDENTIAL versions with Exhibits)Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC’s Response to Respondents’ Motion for Protective Order and Memorandum of Law Related Thereto.pdf21-11_C_Rsp_R_Mtn_Public.pdf 72372
4208/31/2022Served Order on Respondents' Motions to Partially Dismiss and for a Protective Order and Complainant's Motion for Expedited ReliefServed Order on Respondents' Motions to Partially Dismiss and for a Protective Order and Complainant's Motion for Expedited Relief.pdf21-11_Ord_R_Mtn_C_Mtn_Relief.pdf 72383
4309/01/2022Received Complainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited Discovery to Address Matters Ruled on in the Presiding Officer's August 31, 2022 OrderComplainant OJ Commerce, LLC's Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited Discovery to Address Matters Ruled on in the Presiding Officer's August 31, 2022 Order.pdf21-11_C_Mtn_Relief_Sept2022.pdf 72386
4409/01/2022Received Notice of Respondents' Intent to Oppose Complainant's Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited DiscoveryNotice of Respondents' Intent to Oppose Complainant's Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited Discovery.pdf21-11_R_Notc_Oppose_C_Sept2022.pdf 72387
4509/01/2022Received Respondents' Motion to CompelRespondents' Motion to Compel.pdf21-11_R_Mtn_Compel_Sept2022.pdf 72389
4609/01/2022Received Complainant's Response to Notice of Respondents' Intent to Oppose Its Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited DiscoveryComplainant's Response to Notice of Respondents' Intent to Oppose Its Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited Discovery.pdf21-11_C_Rsp_R_Opposition_Sept2022.pdf 72390
4709/07/2022Received Respondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited DiscoveryRespondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Expedited Relief Concerning Extension of Time for Limited Discovery.pdf21-11_R_Opp_C_Mtn_Limited.pdf 72398
4809/08/2022Received Respondents' Motion to Compel and Complainant's Counterstatement and Opposition to Respondents' Motion to CompelReceived Respondents' Motion to Compel and Complainant's Counterstatement and Opposition to Respondents' Motion to Compel.pdf21-11_C_CState_Opp_R_Compel.pdf 72402
4909/22/2022Received Complainant's Motion for Clarification of the Presiding Officer's August 31, 2022 OrderReceived Complainant's Motion for Clarification of the Presiding Officer's August 31, 2022 Order.pdf21-11_Mtn_Clarification.pdf 72456
5009/26/2022Received Respondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Clarification of the Presiding Officer's August 31, Order Received Respondents’ Opposition to Complainant’s Motion for Clarification of the Presiding Officer's August 31, Order.pdf22-11_RESP_Opposition to Motion for Clarification.pdf 73456
5109/30/2022Served Order on Respondent's Motion to Compel and Complainant's Motions for Extension of Time and for ClarificationServed Order on Respondent's Motion to Compel and Complainant's Motions for Extension of Time and for Clarification.pdf21-11 Order on Respondent's Motion to Compel.pdf 74470
5210/06/2022Served Notice Not to ReviewServed Notice Not to Review.pdf21-11_Notice_Not_Review_NS.pdf 74480
5310/10/2022Received Complainant's Notice of Appearance Received Complainant's Notice of Appearance.pdf21-11 Notice of Appearance of Jacob Weiss.pdf 74483
5411/10/2022Received Complainant's Proposed Findings of Fact (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Complainant's Proposed Findings of Fact.pdf21-11 Complainant's Proposed Findings of Facts.pdf 76581
5511/10/2022Received Complainant's Brief (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions with Appendix of Exhibits)Received Complainant's Brief.pdf21-11 Complainant's Brief.pdf 76582
5612/08/2022Received Respondent's Motion for Confidential Treatment of Certain MaterialsReceived Respondent's Motion for Confidential Treatment of Certain Materials.pdf21-11 Respondent's Motion for Confidential Treatment of Certain Materials.pdf 77641
5712/09/2022Served Notice of Extension of TimeServed Notice of Extension of Time.pdf21-11 Notice of Extension of Time (ns).pdf 77644
5812/13/2022Received Respondents' Reply to Complainant's Proposed Finding of Fact (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Respondents' Reply to Complainant's Proposed Finding of Fact (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions).pdf21-11 PUBLIC UNRESTRICTED Respondents Reply to Complainants PFF.pdf 77649
5912/13/2022Received Respondents' Proposed Finding of Facts (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions with Appendix)Received Respondents' Proposed Finding of Facts (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions with Appendix).pdf21-11 PUBLIC UNRESTRICTED Respondents Proposed Findings of Fact.pdf 77650
6012/13/2022Received Respondents' Brief (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions)Received Respondents' Brief (Public and CONFIDENTIAL Versions).pdf21-11 PUBLIC UNRESTRICTED Respondents' Brief.pdf 77651
6112/23/2022Received Complainant's ReplyReceived Complainant's Reply.pdf21-11 PUBLIC Complainant's Reply_Redacted.pdf 79684
6212/23/2022Received Complainant's Responses to Respondents Proposed Findings of Fact (Public and Confidential versions with Appendix)Received Complainant's Responses to Respondents Proposed Findings of Fact (Public and Confidential versions with Appendix).pdf21-11 PUBLIC Complainant's Responses to Respondents' Proposed Findings of Fact_Redacted (23).pdf 79685
6312/23/2022Received Complainant's Appendix - Supplement (Public and Confidential version)Received Complainant's Appendix - Supplement (Public and Confidential version).pdf21-11 PUBLIC Complainant's Appendix - Supplement_Redacted (23).pdf 79686